I started a metaverse game tonight about 7:15 CST, and finished and posted it about an hour later. Then I've been trying to start another one since about 9pm. I keep getting some error that the metaverse is returning some unknown reply (I forget the exact wording).
Any one else seeing this?
Point conceded on the MV. For me, however, there is a much larger issue in play now. Brad has been all over the demigod forum, as well he should, but has not taken the time to say one word to the GalCiv2 community. It wold only take 10 min for him to come over here and diffuse the growing resentment that has been building on our forums. Had he the class to address this issue on Day 1, like he should have, I would be first in line to defend stardock against their detractors. Now, I am among the leading critics. I am not alone either. An insurrection is brewing in the GalCiv community over stardock's obvious apathy towards this game. A suprising attitude from stardock, considering the major release to retail outlets that just happened. How many posts do we keep seeing where people complain about nonresponsive customer service?What is it going to take to get stardock (ie Brad) to make a simple statement to us?
Kind of like the puppy and the old hound. Owner used to visit and play with the hound everyday. Then along came the new puppy hogging all the attention. In the meantime the poor old hound just had to sit back and wait for his leaking doghouse to be fixed.
Yeah good points.
Snark I solute you.
Seconded.
Guys, Pat is giving the Metaverse issue as much time as he can spare. The metaverse is an old and finicky beast of code and I don't think there's really anyone else familiar enough with its innards to try fixing it. I understand it's a bit frustrating and sympathize, but you *can* still play the game even if you don't get scored for it (we do play the game for the "fun" part, right?).
It's no secret that everyone is spending the bulk of their time working on Demigod. It's not out of any desire to abandon GC2 (we are still planning another patch at some point, as you know). But there are a lot of people who just bought Demigod and cannot play the primary part of the game (multiplayer) reliably, or in some cases, at all.
I know you guys probably won't like to hear it, but not being able to play rates a fair bit higher than not being able to record game stats, so it's only logical that that's where the bulk of our efforts are going to be until that's dealt with (and we *hope* to get it squashed no later than early next week).
All I can ask for is your patience. I'm not going to lie to you and say it's going to be fixed instantly; we're doing what we can with what we've got.
Thanks Kryo. You make good points mate, and we understand, priorities must be set.
It might be a bit much to ask but i think alot of guys are feeling abandoned by Brad and could do with his presence here if only just for a quick post to give some reassurance's from the boss that the future of the MV is indeed being looked after.
Thanks Kyro any news is better than no news but in the meantime it might behove Brad to think about giving us a modicum of his time. We are also the customers who will BUY a new game based on how the older games performed over time. Taken into consideration that many of us are going into withdrawl by not getting into metaverse is one thing, not being worth the Boss's time is another altogether and will hurt the bottom line way more in the long run. Still think GC2 is the best game out there bar none and will continue to support Stardock and by implication Impulse because of this ONE game. Take the time that is needed to fix the metaverse for the long term but please let Brad know we are still paying customers...for future games and expansions.
I'm a little suprised people want to hear from Mr Wardell these days. To be honest, I like having Kryo as the voice of reason and wisdom. I can understand people have this 'connection' with Brad because of the way he operates Stardock by interfacing with the paying customers and I guess it is inherent in human nature to expect more. However, do the likes of Sid Meier talk to the gaming public; consider when it took as long as it did for the latest update to Civ IV Beyond the Sword, or Colonization for that matter to be patched? No, it was in fact other members of staff who shared the good news that patches were on the way, and not even much in the way of information at all. I don't think there are too many designers that interface often with the gaming public.
Which brings me to another point: it tooks months before Firaxis set about patching their games. If there is one thing I like with Stardock, it is the ongoing support they provide with games, not least of which that Kryo mentioned above is another patch for Gal Civ II being planned, not bad considering the game is hitting the three year mark soon I think.
That said, in all seriousness, do we need a post from Frogboy to cover what has already been said?
And I know, I know... This sounds like a bit of a fanboy rant though I don't intend it to be, but rather more of trying to inject a bit of a balanced view.
Going by the majority of responses in this thread and others i have seen elsewhere, we do seem to need Brad's input on this.
I do not, i fully understand SD's position and have believed for some time that GC2 is no longer the priority it once was. Kryo's comments cement what i have already been saying, they will get to fixing it, eventually.
That being said, i also understand many of my friends thoughts and feelings on this and can see where they are coming from. Having Brad be part of the scene here for so long and then to see what looks like an abandonment can be frustrating.
Many GC2er's feel that they helped get the ball rolling with SD and their Gaming dept and as such feel snubbed somewhat by the new kids on the block.
I understand that and can't say i don't feel the same. But it comes down to money and where it is going to be made.
But one cannot argue that the continued support of the many GC2 users out there is not worth 10 Mins of Brad's time.
There are going to be those, such as yourself Strato and me, that are fine with how this is playing out.
Others want..need to be able to hear the situation from the boss and be able to air their frustrations to him as well.
Can't hurt.
To me, this whole Demigod thing is just more Stardock Shinanigans. It's more of the same poor testing and control.
They pushed out yet another game early, and now are in fire fight mode. Once again they'll battle the big problems, and probably never get around to balancing the game, and polishing it.
Then we'll hear about how many wonderfull updates stardock put out to support the game. Bogus.
As I said earlier I share as much frustration as anyone about the MV being down.
Showing support for the metaverse is good. But doing so by denigrating SD is counter productive at best.
@Kryo - I'm sorry but I feel compelled to ask SD a few tough questions. I'd sincerely like you to answer these questions in a forthright and honest manner.
1. Did SD not have a back-up server for the MV?
2. Did SD back-up the MV server every night?
3. Did SD have a disaster recovery plan?
Our problem is the same as the Demigod folks Kryo; we can't play either. There is no way to start an MV game right now. If it was just a matter of posting scores none of us would care if it took a few weeks. We're being asked to not play our favorite game for an uncertain amount of time while Demigod gets first priority. Certain people indicate they understand that. I frankly do not. On the homepage of the GalCiv forums it says:
Friday 24th, 9 days later, MV still down... aaagh!
Someone mentioned Civ4 - is that a good alternative until this gets fixed?
Cheers
clanlindsey, it has nothing to do with hardware or backups. The metaverse software is not behaving correctly. Moving it to other servers has caused trouble in the past, so the only option is to troubleshoot it in-place.
An unmodded normal game is identical to a metaverse game, aside from the inability to play for points.You might even take the opportnity to check out some mods and find it even more fun.
The same can't be said of Demigod without multiplayer, since it is a teamwork-oriented game.
CL, I appreciate your frustration but I have a slightly different view and am not worried that the MV is being abandoned for good. (As mentioned, the GC1 MV is still around!)
First, games are not Stardock's "bread and butter," at least not yet. Other work earns them more money, as far as I know. Second, the problem is not with lost backups it is a matter of infrastructure overload. Demigod is MP-only, and is in a critical launch phase, so it is reasonable that they focus work their first. I suspect it is also possible that getting Demigod squared away will be the better part of fixing the MV, so even if we're not getting the kind of direct-from-Brad updates that the Demigod folks are getting, we're probably "getting some help" even as we type.
Perhaps more importantly, maybe now's the time for MV lovers to try some real free play--check out a mod, build and playtest a (hopefully very silly) custom civ to carry the Twilight Pub's flag, or find a friend who does textures and build a fleet of tartan-hulled ships. The MV added some fun to the game for me, but it is by no means all there is to enjoying GC2. As far as I know, the Demigod folks *really* can't play without the network infrastructure.
p.s. If I didn't know how good Scots are at grumbling, I'd say that your rant is a clear sign you really do belong with us boring old Gerontocrats
Edit: Oh well, guess the MV is a bit ill all in its own right after all.
This is the type on information we should have been seeing a week ago. It would have prevented most of our rants. The more specific the explanation, the more likely we are to accept the situation and move along.
So:
1) The problems are software-related rather than hardware-related.
2) There is only one person (Pat) who can fix it. Pat has limited availability due to other obligations.
3) The metaverse cannot be transferred to another server, it must be repaired in-place.
Don't be shy about dropping more detail on us. We're much smarter than any other gaming forum community. We can handle it.
@GW: I can skin. That's not a bad idea. Hehe. Tartan-hulled ships. I like it!
Ach, ye may well be right, GW. We're known for grumbling, being tight with our money, and being strong engineers. The latter being my primary source of frustration right now. Kryo is saying that the MV only works on one server...and although back-ups of the hard drive weren't mentioned, they're either not done or won't fix the problem. That's an all your eggs in one very fragile basket situation and the gods always come along and smack you around for that type of thing. Computers fail, hard drives fail, viruses abound, buildings burn down....it doesn't take Demigod to knock out the MV with this type of situation, nearly anything can. And it will, sure as Scots pinch their pennies. SD needs a redundancy plan and a disaster recovery plan; I hope they learn that from this situation. I'm really not trying to be a PITA (pain in the ass) but these answers are not satisfactory in the environment I come from. If SD were a bank, a hospital, an insurance company....the feds would have shut them down a long time ago. What I keep hearing is exactly how vulnerable the MV is and no one seems to think there's anything wrong with that. The situation is what it is, but c'mon, this is a critical failure in an engineering/syetems/software environment....the Scots in me is finding it hard to let this go. I'm not trying to rant, and I hope I don't sound like I am, but I'm very shocked and aghast and what I'm actually hearing: the MV is completely dependent on one creaky server, a recalcitrant software snarl, and a single person named Pat. I'm not sure why it's only me that has his eyes bug out when he hears that. Maybe it's my Scots side, we're kind of genetically hardwired to fix things like this. I'll just shut up now.
Tartan colored ships, though,,,,now there's an idea!
See, Kryo, we're already starting to calm down. So howsabout giving us a full and complete assessment on the metaverse server so that we can ease our overactive imaginations and get down to the business of producing scottish-themed game accessories? I don't think that's such an unreasonable request, do you?
I mean it's one thing to intellectually know that this is being addressed but it's just as important for folks to get a little reassurance now and then. Any info like this that you can spare would be both extremely helpful and very much appreciated.
Uhmm...
Sorry GW, Demigod does have a Single Player skirmish and tournament mode.
Which makes this comment Kryo somewhat confusing..
As much as the GC2 folk can still play a sandbox game, much can be said for Demigod players doing the same. The single player functions are just as fun as a sandbox GC2 game.
Not that i think another excuse is needed, but that one just doesnt hold water.
Just being devils advocate...if you will....sorta.
In GC2, you're still playing against the AI whether you're in the normal sandbox or in the meta. The scoring is a meta-game addition, and does not affect the gameplay itself in any substantive way aside from the prohibition on mods.
With Demigod, the AI is a significantly different game than multiplayer, where you can actually work together and play against other users in real time. Multiplayer is the main focus of the game, and if it's not working then that's a very big issue.
Not that im debating the need for more focus on Demigod over GC2, i get that and even agree to a point but i want to point out that a games use is very subjective.
When i bought GC2 way..way back when..i cared not for the MV. For the first few months the MV may as well have not exsisted. Then i was a MV only player, much like many of the foks in this thread.
With Demigod, again i care not for the MP aspects. I like to play at my own pace/schedule, so the MP side of it is right out the window for me, the single player is all i need. Though i will admit i will check out MP when it's ironed out, but its not the determining factor in my purchase.
I'm more than happy to concede that the majoirty of folks prolly bought DG for the MP aspect..but certainly not all.
But more so, there are many..many folks who have bought GC2 simply for the Meta.
As i said, agreed. Let's just hope that the DG issues are fixed fast, at this point i can't play the MV or DG online.....LOL
Play some Peggle Neilo...you'll be alright.
DAMN THAT GAME!!!!
Well yeah but,
Those places all have orders of magnitude more Money, Time and Experience dealing with reliability issues like this plus they running very old probably simpler code. They are also legally required to do the reliability stuff and have been for a long time y2k, SarbOx, etc. its literally their 3rd priority - works at all, doesn't lose money, keeps working and easily restarted after SHTF.
This is entertainment so its works at all, is fun, makes money, fun, fun, fun, and then maybe keeps working.
I'm doing sandbox tinies to sharpen up.
There are many great features available to you once you register, including:
Sign in or Create Account