Release Status: *** AVAILABLE ***
Our April update is a bit modest, with a focus on bug fixes and balance changes. Players will also find more updated graphics, UI refinements, and updated sound FX for our existing systems.
April marks the last major update for Sins of a Solar Empire II until August 2024. We’ll still be working hard on the game and have a lot in store for everyone; but we need to batten down and focus to get everything done. In the meantime, you’ll start seeing more dev diaries, news, live streams and other coverage as we lead up to the August update.
As a small preview of what to expect later this summer:
The Advent Unity returns with a vengeance!
New planet types and special gravity wells.
New damage FX for ships and structures.
Custom UI skins per race.
New maps and victory conditions.
New dynamic music system and many more tracks.
More minor factions.
Diplomacy and primary AI improvements.
Modding tools
Thank you to all our players for taking this journey with us. We hope you’ll stay with us a bit longer while we prep the massive Advent update for later this year!
(Test Edition): We were finally able to repro the rare issue affecting some users who couldn’t get the game to launch and would get a 0xc0000142 exe error dialog. We tracked this down and believe we have it fixed now (at least our test case no longer reproduces). If you were having this error, please try the Test Edition build and let us know if it fixes things.
Fixed several rare crashes.
The final ‘spit and polish’ update for real (until the summer update):
Added progress bar to research window buttons on the top bar.
Added available civilian slots indicator to open structure window button.
Added research tier column background highlight on mouseover.
Fixed Steam Deck crash bug.
Note: We are not officially supporting Steam Deck at this time.
Fixed “Apply Mod” crash.
Added Advent summer teaser loading screen. 😄
Added lots more 2D artwork.
Updated a few strings.
Added even more 2D icon and button artwork.
Various string updates (English).
v1.21.10.1 - Fix for an insanely rare crash that was 50 years in the making (seriously).
v1.21.10.2 - Added more 2D icon and button artwork.
v1.21.11 (5/1/24)
Fixed another super rare crash bug we found.
Fixed some incorrectly hooked up 2D assets.
LAN mode is now enabled!
Added more 2D icon/button/background artwork.
v1.21.7 - Fixes not being able to load recent save games and recordings.
Updated load screen key art.
Improved front-end background scene lighting.
Improved lighting on player theme selection mesh.
Improved colonized planets window layout.
Fixed diplomacy window watermark layout.
Fixed exotic factory watermark.
Fixed various HUD watermark layouts.
Improved empire units window layout.
Improved player theme picker window when random race is selected.
Improved trade window layout.
Updated front-end to use glowing dialog frame for all backdrops.
Added a variety of other Vasari research icons and pictures.
Added Vasari beam research pictures.
Added pulse and wave research pictures.
Added improved placeholder HUD icons for Vasari ships.
Added new SFX for Vasari Heavy and Medium beam weapons.
Added new SFX for Vasari Disintegration beam ultimate.
Added new SFX for Vasari anti-armor beam SFX.
Fixed crash when opening HUD keybindings group.
Rebalanced capital ship resource costs: Capital Ships are extremely potent units, so much so that ‘mass capital ship’ has become a dominant strategy in the early game for all factions. This is partially due to their excellent cost efficiency and survivability. We like how they perform in combat, and still want to support capital ship heavy fleet compositions, but they need to become a less economically efficient option, especially early in the game. Therefore, their resource costs have been increased.
TEC capital ship cost increased to 2500/850/600 (from 2500/770/480)
Vasari capital ship cost increased to 0/1800/1320 (from 0/1400/1100).
Rebalanced civilian structure costs.
Rebalanced corvette vs light frigate interactions.
Rebalanced early game research progression.
Rebalanced frigate and cruiser costs: Frigates and cruisers were quite expensive for what they provided, especially in comparison to capital ships. Their prices have been reduced in almost every case in order to ensure they are worth building when compared to the more versatile capital ships.
Rebalanced Influence recharge rate from Culture.
Rebalanced Influence to come from tech research instead of the home planet bonus.
Rebalanced Vasari Kortul abilities: The Kortul has a highly versatile and powerful ability set and was becoming dominant in Vasari fleets. It has had its first three abilities reduced in power somewhat, especially at the lower levels, while receiving an increase to the AOE damage and pierce of Volatile Nanites. This should provide more choice between spamming many low level Kortuls and trying to level one or two Kortuls to higher levels.
Rebalanced light missile and light phase missile Pierce from 250 to 300. This will increase bomber (both TEC and Vasari) and Tosurak Raider effectiveness against heavy cruisers and capital ships.
Rebalanced Minor Faction abilities for Viturak and Jiskun. The Jiskun Expedition has had its Scout Vision ability moved to level 3 to make it more accessible. Meanwhile, it loses Tachyon Boost and gains Phase Space Raid at level 4. The Viturak Cabal gains Tachyon Boost at level 3, with Phase Space Raid moved to the Jiskun.
Rebalanced Minor Faction rebuild potential.
Rebalanced Minor Faction reveal and level up costs.
Rebalanced TEC Rebel titan rail gun: Cooldown decreased from 12 to 10; damage decreased from 960 to 800.
Rebalanced Vasari titan phase cannons: Range increased from 8,000 to 10,000; cooldown decreased from 12 to 9; damage decreased from 1200 to 900.
Rebalanced Pranast United Minor Faction. Pranast United rewards have been re-ordered based on a more practical assessment of their value. Notably, the Protection Fleet now requires level 4 with the Minor Faction, meaning it needs 6 Influence and takes 480 seconds to cooldown. This should prevent egregious early game spamming by players not investing in any Influence boosting items.
Rebalanced pursuit criteria.
Updated Radiation Bomb: The requirement for the ship to face its target in order to use the Radiation Bomb has been removed in order to help the TEC deal with swarms of light units.
Rebalanced ship speed and gravity well size. A small increase to gravity well size and the speed of many ships should give a little more room to maneuver, especially as fleets get large in the late game. Scouts see the most drastic increase to speed, which should help them live a little longer and do their job more effectively.
Rebalanced Skirantra elite bombers and Vasari bomber Armor item. This ability and item combination could result in Vasari bombers having an absurd 500 hull, rendering them almost invulnerable to their counters. Both required significant value reductions to bring Vasari bombers back into line as units counterable by fighters and point defense.
Rebalanced titan armor strength and shield proportions: Titans had excessively high Armor strength, resulting in an uneven feeling damage curve in big fights. In order to smooth this curve, Armor strength has been reduced, allowing Shield Points to be increased without changing the total effective survivability of titans.
Rebalanced Trade income: Trade has been under-performing quite a bit compared to other sources of economy. In particular, the credit income from Trade is often relatively meager compared to a reasonably sized TEC Commerce economy. Trade credit income has been increased from 1.6 to 2.5, while metal and crystal have both been increased from 0.8 to 1.0. Trade tech upgrades now heavily favor increasing credits from trade instead of equally increasing all resource types. This should help ensure that the TEC can quickly and consistently solve credit shortages through the use of trade.
Rebalanced Trader and Vasari planet upgrade cost scaling.
Rebalanced Trader and Vasari research cost scaling.
Rebalanced Trader frigate and cruiser shields: Increased Shield hit points for smaller TEC ships makes the upgrade techs more meaningful and giving more time for the shields to be seen during combat.
Rebalanced Vasari bombers: The Vasari bomber has been reduced from 4 missiles per salvo back to 2. They have also had their HP reduced by a third. These changes should help point defense more effectively suppress them.
Vasari carrier capital squadrons reduced by 1.
Rebalanced Vorastra Phase Tunneling to use AU (astronomical unit) range.
Rebalanced weapon burst counts for Vasari pulse guns.
Changed Viturak’s Deploy Phase Gate to max out at 3 within an empire.
Units told to move to a specific position will not attempt to move back to the fleet unless the fleet is issued new orders or the unit is told to move to the fleet.
Added auto-join fleet to actions that change player ownership. Makes Pirate Boarding Crews not so clunky to use.
Disabled research starting and updating if research points have been lost. Previously, once the tier was acquired you could lose all research points and still research within that tier. This is no longer possible.
Disabled research tier bonus modifiers if research points are lost.
Fixed allocated trade points being lost when upgrading tech colony capital ship ability.
Fixed being on the same team as Vasari Alliance player not giving initial access to friendly minor factions and trade points.
Fixed Phase Resonance bonus time items not working properly.
Fixed Vasari Alliance initial detection of all friendly minor factions being broken.
Fixed units being added to other player’s fleets if rallying to another player's units.
Fixed units rallying to fleet losing their follow orders.
Prevented roaming minor factions from killing player home planets. Aluxians should no longer be wiping out pirates and human players due to bad luck on galaxy generation.
Improved raid retreat conditions. Siege frigates will now stick around to keep attacking the planet.
Fixed minor factions not able to start with starbases.
Changed minor faction level up Influence point cost to be per-level within the minor faction.
Added infinite alliance locks. This is necessary for research that gives minor faction alliances so that the reputation system doesn't break them on its update (Truce Amongst Rogues was broken).
Fixed Reveal Minor Faction not working properly if minor faction is dead.
Improved AI logic around if it should attack other gravity wells. Will now consider allied fleets as well.
Improved AI siege frigate building. Was building too many under certain circumstances.
Added unit pursue target definition and logic.
Disabled AI fleets from being active when player has lost.
Fixed unit AI not attacking if stuck in a gravity well due to Phase Inhibitor AND the fleet leader is in a different gravity well.
Added player AI building research structures to improve research rates.
Fixed AI building multiple titan factories when only one needed.
Fixed AI building too many of one capital ship type based on exotics it might have received.
Fixed AI sometimes stranding some remote fleet units.
Fixed fleet AI stuck in an attack/defend feedback loop when trying to defend a different planet.
Fixed player AI not attacking other players as it should.
Fixed player AI not spreading Culture.
Improved unit AI target picking when no targets within weapon range.
Improved unit auto-cast target picking distribution.
Increased priority of AI explorer ship building so Jiskun ability doesn't become useless.
Added focus fire input modifier by holding ALT. Will enable the old behavior of focus firing an entire stack one-by-one instead of spreading out and attacking closest targets.
Advanced Fleet Menu:
Added Retreat command (ships told to retreat will not instantly attempt to move back to the fleet).
Added toggle "Threat Avoidance Pathing." Default is "No Threat Avoidance Pathing" which is equivalent to the shortest path.
Added slow pan with keyboard when holding Shift.
Right-click to join a fleet will now also move to that fleet leader.
Fixed camera detaching from ship if it is last to leave a gravity well.
Added new Influence window art and layout.
Added new Influence points icon.
Added damage and pierce to torpedo tooltips.
Added dynamic resizing to the minor factions window based on UI scaling and number of rows.
Added map details to lobby window.
Added new auction bid amount notification backdrop.
Added planet counts to front-end scenario picker.
Added unit constraint specifics to failed is target valid error messages. For example, "Target must be in your dominant culture".
Changed click to reveal text to be all uppercase.
Changed team picker to be a grid of buttons instead of a drop box.
Compressed Influence points text in Minor Faction window.
Converted research_time modifiers to research_rate. This aligns the display of research_rate to the user; previously needed a hack to reinterpret time scalar as a research rate bonus (invert the scalar).
research_time
research_rate
Fixed modding window not clipping long names.
Fixed planet bonus discovered notification not focusing on the planet when clicked.
Hid auto-cast indicator of ship abilities for other players.
Improved drag and drop UI in lobby window. Makes it more obvious how to move players to other teams.
Improved fleet tooltip of aggregated deliverables. Will now aggregate counts to named capital ships.
Improved player slot dragging tooltip to describe how to make uneven teams.
Improved research required tooltip on abilities.
Invert slot count in join game list - show closed instead of open.
Made default fleet names uppercase. To match rename forcing uppercase as well (like ships).
Fixed hyperspace color of order lines not being used if fleet destination is destroyed in-transit.
Changed research rate scalar in tooltip to be a positive value. Due to it being labeled as rate bonus even though the modifier is a time scalar.
Fixed horizontal tiling brush rendering.
Fixed item buttons in planet/fleet windows not working properly. Would be using the current selection instead of the actual items under the cursor.
Fixed right-click no longer dismissing notification cards. Was broken due to change in logic to get auction notification working (right-click for it will change bid amount backward).
Fixed attack user interface giving target not detected error when explicitly attacking targets.
Added more mesh point stubs for center/aura/above.
Added new effect visibility system. Particularly important for weapons fire visuals and gameplay signaling. You can now see the glorious pew pew from a distance!
Added siege beam for siege platform and other assets.
Increased beam effect count.
Updated TEC explosion effects.
Reduced length of missile trails.
Reduced planet elevator counts now that planet levels are higher.
Added settings for particle effect scaling.
Added unit dialogue sound throttling. No longer able to spam infinite voice events over one another with certain user interface actions like giving orders.
Added sound FX for colony shuttle launches.
Added sound FX for TEC and Vasari colony capital ship Colonize abilities.
Added sound FX for TEC colony frigate ability.
Added sound_group to various sound files. This limits the number of simultaneous SFX that can play within a group.
sound_group
Added/Updated Vasari Medium Pulse Gun/Wave Cannons SFX.
Fixed attenuation and loop on Jam Weapons.
TEC SFX Naming Refactor: Refactored SFX naming scheme to be consistent across the board.
Added new Raze Planet muzzle SFX.
Updated Nanite Swarm SFX.
Updated TEC capital ships and titans to use new SFX (i.e., missed some hookups).
Added customized Physical Point Defense alt SFX.
Created new sound for Vasari strikecraft engines.
Adjusted phase space charge SFX to be shorter (so it doesn't audibly play longer than intended). Slightly shortened phase space exit SFX, so there's no apparent delay on exit.
Made Vasari phase missile muzzle SFX a touch more oomphy.
Added new sound FX for Nanite Armor ambient.
Added new sound FX for Nanite Hull Repair ambient.
Fixed some dropouts and looping issues with phase space sound FX.
Added new phase missile muzzle sound FX.
Added new pulse gun sound FX.
Added new wave cannon sound FX.
Hooked up all missing impact sound FX to Vasari carrier and colony caps.
Removed charge sound FX from light wave cannons; reserving it for medium/heavy only.
Fixed player notification dialogue not using dialogue volume. Previously, there was no distinction between UI and dialogue for custom player sounds (they were all considered UI).
Fixed Missing Characters in Chinese. Thanks to ansker for letting us know.
Localization formatting fixes.
Spanish localization update. Thanks to SrtaBurner for the fixes!
Updated Simplified Chinese Translation. Thanks to ansker for the fixes!
Fixed language code not being converted to lowercase and dashes changed to underscores.
Added localized text reloads when the language setting is changed while the game is running.
Added empire limits to Minor Faction reputation spawn unit abilities.
Added empire modifiers to buffs.
Added random skybox filling uniforms. This allows making skybox only mods without mutating galaxy generator uniforms, because by doing so these mods would be marked as NON-cosmetic and not usable in multiplayer.
Added support for child meshes to be visible based on unit item levels (not just existence of an item). Needed for new design of titan armor which is upgradable through research.
Changed scenario_scene to use random_fixture_filling instead of a raw list of entities. Makes it easier to mod the front end background scenario look.
scenario_scene
random_fixture_filling
Changed scenario_scenes to use random_skybox_filling instead of a raw vector of skybox names. This indirection allows skybox mods that don't need to overwrite the front end scenario (background scene).
scenario_scenes
random_skybox_filling
Fixed modding changes not fully applying all changes until exe restarts.
Fixed subscribers total using downloads total in mod.io tooltip.
Added unit_constraint_value_source to improve constraint authoring readability.
unit_constraint_value_source
Fixed planet counts for Annulus.
Adjusted collision to reduce units getting too packed together.
Fixed flip-flopping of collision avoidance.
Fixed crash when changing the name of fleet when the game is paused in single-player.
Fixed Excavation track button assert when excavated planet changes ownership.
Fixed Phase Resonance crash involving strikecraft and player ownership changes.
Fixed recorded game crash due to player and skin issues. The wrong planet skin was being preloaded when jumping around recorded games causing the planet_mesh to be unloaded (because later in the recorded game a planet became owned).
planet_mesh
* Fixed server crash if toggle fleet rally threat avoidance button is pressed.
Fixed scuttling starbases spawning capturable loot exploit.
Fixed being able to use Influence when game is lost.
Fixed future orbits tooltip crash with German language.
Currently not available while we fix a pesky assert. Back soon!
Must be quite a bug if it's still not released (unless I downloaded it and didn't realize). I've been holding off on playing again until the next update.
It's available now.
v1.25.5 saved single player games do not show up in the load game dialog.
Did you mean 1.21.5? Weird, working on my side. Do you know how to recreate it? Would love to fix it for you
Tried again after my post and it worked fine.
Looked like an update had happened and didn't recognize the previous version save.
Do you know what version you were on previously when you made the save game? Today's update should have been compatible with 1.21.4 save games.
Question, since its going from Sins 1 to Sins 2, there arent any new units? That seems rather odd for a second iteration of the game. In fact, we lost some units and even a capitol ship from game 1. Is that in the works at all? A new capitol ship? Or maybe a ship between capitol and titan?
That's usually how to appeal to players of the original game give them more toys and ships and more ships.
Not in this case...they have capitols running away in a undermined state because they can't protect themselves and they eliminated a frigate that could be a protector.
And they are still technically in the building stage of the game. Better to start at a base level, aka the original ships, and add to it from there. We don't know what the final product will be. Especially as they have modified or added to much of the structure of the game, aka orbital planets, new economics, even new battle concepts, so that new ships are a bit over the top right now.
Not going play Monday night quarterbacks and second guess your business decisions, cause lets be honest this is a business decisions not betterment for the fans, the brand or the game. If you want us to buy your expansions packs you are already planning on creating, you better step up your plans for this game.
I can only speak for myself and if you want more of my money (already starting to regret joining this beta) maybe you actually do what players want:
New gameplay - kinda in progress maybe
Better graphics - check. ( you did the minimum) hopefully there is more
New ships and structures - Not seeing it. Did you really try to justify removing content and not adding a viable replacement ?
my 2 cents and if this view is not the same as the rest, you will only really lose my future money.
I'll take that as neutral or maybe slightly positive. I think all the new features, content, and mechanics do bring a lot of new gameplay to the table without ruining what Sins was. A lot of it isn't immediately obvious but we'll try and do better to expose it. Also, Advent will bring some additional new gameplay.
Thanks. Yes, there are more graphical improvements coming. Working on some this weekend in fact.
I listed a few new units above but there are more in-game. Also, when Advent arrives they will bring a few more.
That is a good question and fundamental to the game. If we removed a unit and didn't have a viable replacement then the tactical (and potentially strategic) interactions of the game wouldn't work (at least for the race in question). However, as I admitted we did find a couple holes that may require a new unit (or rework) to fix. If you have a specific unit that was removed that doesn't have a viable replacement, we are happy to dig into it because it could mean there are some broken interactions we don't know about yet.
@Blair Fraser:
Disagree here on a few points, will try to respond to everything and add some feedback thats coming from myself and my brother who I play the game with:
Orbiting planets, new and unique racial mechanics, more racial and sub-faction differentiation, new game systems, new combat mechanics, new high level strategy options, unit and planet customization, new fleet management, new empire management, new minor faction system, multi-core/64bit engine, in-game mod support, and so on service this one goal.
-Orbiting planes - win
- New racial mechanics - ok, but can be pushed more, will wait for final verdict, so far progress
- new combat mechanics - sure
- new fleet/empire managemetn - sure
- mew minor faction system - yes, this has been positive, enjoy that
- New high level strategy - dont think so. And i think this is where we get boggled down a bit. To paraphrase Grubby(Warcraft 3 streamer and big time gaming icon), if the gameplay is sound the game will succeed.
A lot of the "new things" are quality of life changes that are generally linked to a patch, not a whole new game. When you present a new game in the RTS world we as a community expect new units. In every single RTS game that I've ever played and has had a second game delivered, there have at least been some new units along side reworks to other units.
Starcraft > Star craft Brood war > new units
Starcraft Brood War > Star craft 2 > massive differences and new units etc.
Warcraft 2 > Warcraft 3 massive differences and new units
Age of Empires 2 > Age of Empires 3 > massive differences and new civs, units etc.
While I understand the "keep the winning formula" and i think the base fantasy of space battles with "hero" capital ships is awesome and must be kept. But if you want to excite the community you need a bit more new toys and units. Cutting units or ships that didnt feel like they added to the gameplay is fine, but pruning is not the same as adding new units. That might streamline pre-existing gameplay, but it does not contribute to new gameplay which is what Sins 2 should bring over Sins 1.
Specifics to the current gameplay:
-Strike craft are more or less fire and forget and the interaction is minor. Capitol ships dont have a way to deal with them like they did in Sins 1, maybe streamlined, but no new interactions. The flak frigates are not enough of an interaction in my opinion. Plus no active abilities to deal with them.
- Dunov capital ship is not enough of a threat and i currently dont feel like its good enough in its role to be picked over a Kol, Marza, Sova, or Akkan.
- Vulkoras and Antorak capital ships are in the same boat.
- I dont find any use for tier 1 frigates past mid game(Cobalt and Ravastra). The anti-matter burns / CD increase they had in game 1 made them useful post early game. Another prune that just takes away gameplay. Finding ways to make all units relevant all game via abilities/upgrades might add that, but we dont have that currently.
- The Harcka Heavy Cruiser doesnt feel new at all, its basically a TEC copy of the Enforcer, who does the exact same thing but actually has the flavor of having a PD turret. So essentially it just becomes a "type" ship, meaning everyone has it, or at least TEC + Vasari currently. So nothing new here. The Kodiak used to be very tanky, and noticeably tanky, so that was that flavor. Need some more flavor to the Harcka to even think about being "new/redesigned".
- Defensor and Raider are just your standard issue corvettes, so again, it feels like the Harcka treatment of here's a generic unit for everyone and you just play ball.
- The mines an Cielo's, while possibly not great gameplay, again, you're pruning, but not adding anything new. So instead of 4 ways to play, with 2 being bad, now its 2 ways to play. While not a bad decision in a vacuum, it doesnt make a difference if this was Sins 1 just not using those units in terms of pure gameplay.
Final thought, like I mentioned earlier, the fantasy of the game is great, and I think so far there's been a good amount of quality of life changes, but I think if you want to the game to pick up speed or explode even if its just from the Sins 1 community, you need to add more gameplay toys, specifically new units/ships that are usable and add to gameplay instead of just taking away the ones that did not. A failed new ship can be balanced, a pruned bad ship cannot.
Just my 4 cents,(2 from me and 2 from my brother).
I don't agree with the notion that Sins2 "requires more units" because it has a "2" at the end of it; nor do I understand the notion of "new games must have more units". This said, I am curious as to which roles/units are still thought to be missing from sins2. I don't think sins2 has progressed past sins:rebellion (story wise); it strikes me as a "revision 2". I'd assume that future expansions are most likely to introduce new units (story wise, because the factions get a chance to respond to each other in their endless war).
It would be awesome to see some of the old units return for militia & minor factions. As a cameos of ideas-past kinda thing. As much as I'd like to see this I'd rather the devs finish implementing their sins2 goals first. Another take would be to have the minor factions use units/designs that weren't deemed fit for the playable factions but could be used as nods for "what might have been".-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
I really miss rank-n-file units having abilities though...
I also ponder about expanding the component system a little bit. Using TEC cruisers & ship components as an example - Harka cruisers would be given a single component slot. Unlike the capital ships, which can have unique loadouts, the mass produced ships are only set-up to support a single variant at any given time.
For miscellaneous musings:
I think a Sins 2 that focused on small scale battles with more depth per ship should of been the way to go to differentiate from Sins 1.
Crews,Captains,Admirals. etc
Really deep into the tech of each ship.
Maybe at max 100 ships per race but tactical and deep in the Sins world.
It's probably not too late.
I for one am having a blast with the new game as it gets better and better. It is true it doesn't have as many new actual "units" as one would expect in a sequel, however it does have new gameplay so it's more like a re-tuning of the first game and an actual improvement in most respects.
Things I like;
I like how the different factions are truly different now instead of just slightly different.
I like how fleets actually work.
I like how micro has been reduced.
I like how you can now build star bases on their own instead of having to use a clunky builder ship that used fleet capacity (always made it awkward to build a SB in the first game, especially if you capped ships and went over the fleet max).
I like the graphical improvements, though the explosions are a bit underwhelming.
I like how minor factions and influence works now, giving it a new unique gameplay mechanic.
Things I don't like;
No new faction. The first game's lore strongly indicated another faction that the Vasari were fleeing, only to not see nor hear anything more about them.
The lack of new units.
The music still using the old synthesizer from 2008 (or so it sounds).
The sound effects are getting better, but still sound too "pew pew" instead of meaty.
Most common ships have no abilities now and therefor have lost any personality to them being little more than "swarm" ships.
Sounds more like the Homewold series. A perfectly legitimate game wish but quite far from the RTS-4X blend that Sins strived for. Maybe a spin-off could eventually explore that?
On the wider discussion, yes, it is somewhat odd for a sequel to keep that many of the original's units and even drop some without replacements. On the other hand, I'd prefer that to adding stuff for the sake of adding stuff and appreciate the focus on wider gameplay mechanics. "Perfection is achieved not when there is nothing left to add, but when there is nothing left to take away." More focus on units would be more crucial for a traditional RTS.
On customisable cruisers - kind of reminds me of the enchantment system in AoW4 or even the Mods system in AoW: Planetfall. 4 is more high-level in that all units of a class (e.g. all shield or all archer units) get the enchantment, whereas in Planetfall it was specific to that unit type (e.g. all assault troopers, all laser tanks; I simplify slightly). While many players liked the latter variant, I found it too complex for my taste (and maybe its own good) and it would certainly be a lot for Sins2. But I think there are already Mk IIs for some units. Maybe those could involve a single choice how to upgrade them, what specifically the players wants to improve. I'd probably leave it at that and not bother with changing that choice later on. Just smells like too many potential pitfalls. But as a one-off choice for cruisers ... maybe? Of course, it needs to be fun and balancing it could be tricky. No point if there is always a single best choice.
Oh, and yes to abilities for ships. Antimatter sabotage was a neat ability to keep light frigates relevant later in the game in Sins 1. Shame to lose that complexity in 2.
Never heard of those games (and yes, I live under a rock); curious that it was found to be too complicated though. I do think it'd be cool to set each cruiser individually, but that would add a ton of micro to things (this is already possible to add via modding). I just figured that a compromise to a class-refit (or the mentioned enchantment) system may be better for the scale of sins2 (which isn't currently possible via modding, to my knowledge). The things I suggested amounted to a passive stat increase, an ability-based sustain & an ability-based movement - which could both be impeded by anti-ability things for some counterplay)
As for the "single best choice", there will always be one regardless of how the game is set up if playing competitively. Adding/Removing complexity just changes what the script would be for those looking to win easily.
There are many great features available to you once you register, including:
Sign in or Create Account