*graphic courtesy of r_munch –thx!
Background
Back quite some time ago when we were talking about tournaments… WAAYYYYY back when I had that oh so very annoying thread about DG players – tier 1, tier 2 and those to be avoided (http://forums.demigodthegame.com/372184)…
… I had an idea. What if we had a tournament where every player was teamed up with every other player. This means, the tournament will really be about individual excellence. We mix and match teams. You don’t try to form team super perfect – you get an assigned teammate that changes each round. For every win, each player on the team gets 1 point. If you lose, you get nothing. We do this until we go through the combinations. The winner is the person with the most points as they were clearly the most effective on each team. In the event of a tie… well… I’ll figure something out. So, as you can see, this tournament is going to be structured VERY differently than our previous ones. If all is well with the brackets, you will play on the same team with every single person exactly 1 time.
The Brackets
Although it probably doesn’t sound all that challenging to pull off, we actually had quite a bit of difficulty coming up with a decent bracket that would enable us to have the tournament they way we wanted it. Thankfully, sledge was kind enough to help out and take the time to develop the brackets so I wouldn’t be doing all of the heavy lifting here. Please give him some karma if you think of it. At any rate, here’s a link to the brackets. Please take a look to help get a better understanding of how things will work. https://spreadsheets.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0An02sqdF5v-EdG1hLTI1d3prLWpnWUpSRnNrbG9RMFE&hl=en_US&authkey=CLWZtdgO
Be aware that we will have EXACTLY 16 players in this tournament. In the event that we only have 15 players, we will add in 1 enhanced AI, etc
What is the schedule?
We should spend some time discussing this. Technically, we could start immediately. As you can see from the brackets, all you need is 3 other folks online at the same time to get a game in. I propose that we setup some specifics dates and times that will be considered game days. We can all show up during this time windows, pair up, and get some games in.
Payouts will be delivered by PayPal. If you don’t have a PayPal account, get one. If you can’t do that, then you will not receive a payout for the cash prizes if you win. If you do win, provide me with your PayPal addresses via pm on these forums and I will get you sorted in short order. If the needed PayPal email address has not been provided in 1 week, the prize money is forfeit. Cash is rendered via PayPal in US dollars. If you are from another country, the conversion is provided by PayPal. Any fee charged by PayPal will come directly out of your winnings (so its possible the winners could receive less than the listed payout).
Thankfully, we have not had a need to disqualify any teams yet during our tournaments, but here are the ground rules.
I want join too
doggu is also in.
Sledge has been working on the match ups.
Uuh. Then its 13 and that means its even harder to get a schedule. Thats much harder than I thought and I could not find anything on the internet. Been working on a 12 player schedule but couldnt get it done. For 4 its easy and I solved it yesterday for 8. Was now working on 12 but have to go to 16. Maybe thats easy when I build it on the 8 schedule. Still trying.
Thanks for sharing my brain pain, sledge. Believe me... it sounds simple to create the chart... but.... its not.
If anyone thinks we are goofs, we'd appreciate anyone that can whip up a chart.
Just a quick update - here is the final list of participants:
Sledge has been trying to make sense of brackets to help out. As soon as we have something sorted, we'll update here. Once the brackets are up, the tourney has begun. You will be free to get a game in anytime you want after that if folks are available. Then we'll have 2-3 set times during the week where folks should try to sign on and get a game going. This should provide some flexibility, but everyone will need to make an effort to get their games in. It shouldn't be all that difficult at first if people make the tiniest effort.
Not sure about that at this point. We will likely create a google spreadsheet for stat tracking and then can give write permissions out as needed.
Someone should collect all replays as proof. Dont need to look at them all but we need some kind of back-up for the stats as after weeks some might not remember a single game.
For the schedule. I am quite positive by now that I understood the logic behind it and just have to try the first match-up then use the system and hope it plays out. So far no luck but one of them should work. But thats for 12, #13 needs to be squeezed in then. Are we sure we are still 13? As for example I have not seen Renz in weeks.
it's difficult to say, tbh. I fully expect some folks to start asking to join and some folks to not show up... methinks you feel a little bit of the organizational pain now eh Not so much fun getting tourneys going
!!!! [HERE FIRST POST EVER] !!!! (Yes, I changed beyond the game, and perhaps even evolved as well, right over there... )So surly : COUNT ME IN !!! As the 14th ....Go Go GO : please find more people !
Lots of goods ideas are simply not exploited ... like an forum about which hour, people would play...I will make sur, as that game, which i have played as the more longest time of my life, is an good end after all... [e digicons]'[/e]
haha - i knew you'd show up tact! I only thought you'd do it immediately after the tourney started. We've had like 5 tourneys - and 4 of them you asked to join immediately after it started.
Please add tact to the roster. Sledge - pm if the brackets make your head explode. I'll make some crazy ruling to get final brackets out quick (tho thx for the hlp).
I had an excel based idea last night, that should speed things up. Give me one or two more days. With 14 I would probably go to a 16 player schedule where there are 1 or 2 games per round not happening as we are missing two players. With 13 I think you could extend a 12 player schedule. Wish me luck.
Bad news. Looking at the working 4 and 8 player schedules you can see a logic behind them why they work. Its too much to go into details but the logic makes sure it works in the end. The only thing that can happen is that it runs into a circle where not everyone play with everyone else but with some players twice. That depends on the first match-ups. I now tried ALL possibilities for the 12 player schedule and they all fail.
Now I do hope that since I have one for 4 and for 8 players it does work for 16 as they are all 2^x which actually could explain why it doesnt work for 12. Something worth mentioning is that with 14 players there are always 2 or 6 players per round that will not get to play as player 15 and 16 dont exist. Which isnt a problem but it might look weird that we will have sometimes only 2 games per round and sometimes 3 games.
Will try to get the 16 schedule tomorrow. My excel idea makes it much easier to test the schedules as it automatically fills in a few numbers according to the mentioned logic.
cmon guys it's not rocket science
heh - you do it zen
YOU GOOGLE IT!!!!
nah - i've looked around. If you even know excel at all and saw the batshite crazy formula I tried to dream up, you'd crap yourself.
r_munch pm'd me something that might work - please look this over and tell me if we are solid:
For example:
#1 = pacov
2= zex
3=munch
4=nnils
5=sledge
6=darkliath
7=hemprx
8=visca
9=mith
10=zen
11=jona
12=dreamcatcher
13=doggu
14=tactical
A: 1,2 VS 3,4
B:1,3 VS 2,4
C:1,4 VS 2,3
D:1,5 VS 6,2
E:1,6 VS 5,2
F:1,7 VS 2,6
G:1,8 VS 2,7
H:1,9 VS 2,8
I:1,10 VS 2,9
j:1,11 VS 2,10
K:1,12 VS 2,11
L:1,13 VS 2,12
M:1:14 VS 2,13
N:2,14 VS 3,5
O:3,6 VS 4,5
P:3,7 VS 4,6
Q:3,8 VS 4,7
R:3,9 VS 4,8
S:3,10 VS 4,9
T:3,11 VS 4,10
U:,3,12 VS 4,11
V:3,13 VS 4,12
W:3,14 VS 4,13
X:4,14 VS 5,6
Y:,5,7 VS 6,8
z:5,8 VS 6,7
AA: 5,9 VS 6,10
BB: 5,10 VS 6,9
CC: 5,11 VS 6,12
DD: 5,12 VS 6,11
EE: 5,13 VS 6,14
FF 5,14 VS 6,13
GG:7,8 VS 9,10
HH: 7,9 VS 10,11
II:7,10 VS 9,8
JJ:7,11 VS 9,12
KK: 7,12 VS 9,13
LL: 7,13 VS 9,14
MM:7,14 VS 8,10
NN:8,11 VS 10,12
OO: 8,12 VS 10,13
PP:8,13 VS 10,14
QQ:8,14 VS 9,11
RR:11,12 VS 14,13
SS:11,13 VS 14,12
TT:11,14 VS 13,12
heh - well hopefully we can sort this to get an official start going. I think we will all have a lot of fun with this tourney.
edit - I will make a ruling in the next few days even if it ends up with us have a flawed bracket. I want to get this going and I'm sure sledge would rather not rack his braing to come up with something that is perfect.
orcun - its ok if you miss out, but I'd hope you'd participate. Honestly, I've only been rushing to try to get you in the game. If you can't make it before you have to travel, though, all is good. I'll create one more tourney that will be a true invitational and will have a super small rooster of players.
I did not really follow all proposition... but if you want make an great solid tournament : that work : how ;14 (all player) × 13 (all player - you) = 182182 ÷ 4 (number of spot...) = 45.5 so 46 (because half match cant count ...)I would had ask for "why not 3vs3?" or free lance match... so other type of tournament. But if you want an solid tour : 3vs3 is the only other solid way and that has another really more hard formula... or well ... if you wanted this one fair : it would theoretically have much more match then 2vs2 formula...
Ok, I can do a better bracket than the one of R-Munch (no offense). In his schedule 1 plays EVERY game either with or against 2. If I take his name example then he has to play all but one game against Nils. Now I know that he will not do well in that tournament in the end. That schedule I would not consider as fair, munch will say I did bad cause I had to play Nils every game and whoever ends second or third will say it was easy for Nils as he could play R_Munch every game.
This will happen a little bit anyways when like the three top players play each other and one of them loses as he had to play with one not-so-top player in that match-up. But having that advantage or disadvantage every single game?
I can make you a more fair schedule than that one in 5 minutes.
Count me in... I can finally play after a looong time..
Ok so after a long day work, I finally get the schedule, want to post that here and the first thing I have to read is a very redneck pm of R_Munch telling me some not so nice words because I didnt like his schedule. But I guess you have to live with guys like that in this community (before someone ask it wasnt like bad to get him banned, so not that low).
So I have not checked the schedule entirely, I just applied the logic and it went through until the end. Its a 16 player schedule, everyone plays everyone else twice and with everyone once. Even if there is a small glitch in there, I think we should take it. I am quite confident though as whenever it doesnt work you notice quite fast.
Could you pm me your mail adress please pacov so I can send it to you?
If Insidious plays and we are 15, then the schedule will for sure work perfect as its exactly one game per round that wont happen, so all is good in the end.
There are many great features available to you once you register, including:
Sign in or Create Account