Okay, I spent a week with Colonization. Unfortunately, as with Empire: Total War, I have been a bit too busy to really give Colonization a real shake. Strangely enough, though, this fact bothered me more with Empire: Total War than it did with Colonization. I can't put my finger on why: perhaps it was Empire's compounded load times (loading the strategic game, loading the battle screen, back to loading the strategic game); perhaps it was that I didn't feel "right" saving in the middle of an epic battle (actually, I'm not even sure if there is a save option there; I suppose there is). With Colonization, there were times when I only had a half hour to play, and I didn't mind just going in and playing for a half hour.
Colonization is a Civ 4 mod and looks the part. This isn't a bad thing: Civ 4 actually looks pretty good to me! My experience with Colonization was very different than with Civ 4, however. In Civ 4, I tend to create a city then create units, and happily go off exploring with the units. Meanwhile, I'm researching and building stuff in the city. In Colonization, I was quickly aware of economics. Every time my population grew, I needed to be aware of food: were we producing enough food? Often, I had to put ideas on hold because I needed more people to produce food.
After some earlier attempts, I realized that I was fixating so much on these economics that I wasn't sending out scouts to explore. More importantly, I wasn't expanding out and creating more settlements. Okay, I need to balance these things!
In the end, it didn't take long before I realized that half hour "what the heck, let me play for a few minutes before bed" would result in several hours.
Anyway, this has been a crazy week for me, so I'm posting this article almost a week later than I had intended. I'm not sure what game I will hammer at next week. I am pondering . . . my XBox 360 is getting lonely, so perhaps this is time to revisit the consoles.
First off, I haven't played Civ 4: Col, but according to PC Gamer reviews, it is more or less an updated graphics version of the original. I have played freecol (free version of original) and can say it is quite fun to play. However, IMO it is a bit narrow for my tastes, especially with the way victory conditions are set up. I would buy it if there was quite a bit of new features from the free original, since it really is a pretty good gameplay concept. But it appeared to be pretty much the same gameplay with only a few exceptions.
Edit: Here's a link to the free version of the original for those interested in Colonization.
http://www.freecol.org/
There are many great features available to you once you register, including:
Sign in or Create Account