Some of you may be aware of the "three strikes" plan recently approved in France, where suspected copyright infringers are liable to be banned from the internet for up to a year if they persist after two warnings, and failed efforts to push similar laws across the entire EU a few months back.
Not content to be rebuffed, proponents of the laws have put them back on the table in Brussels, where they were set to be voted on yesterday. No news seems to be available online yet about how it went (any Europeans visitors have details on that?).
Is banning pirates from the internet going too far, or is it justified? It seems that no amount of DRM ever deters them for long, so perhaps cutting them off from their sources entirely would be the solution to large-scale piracy. Or maybe it just might drive them underground, and result in innocent users being banned on suspicions only. What do you guys think? Could this possibly work, or will it only make matters worse?
Wow DarkKnight is a scary scary guy! Thank goodness there are other rational individuals out there to counter his inane ramblings!
Stardock gets it alright they make a product worth buying and sell it and people buy it (lots of people), no need to break down doors waving the piracy flag.
Uhm DarkKnight I think you need to read what you typed, because if i read correctly you were calling names as well, calling pirates assholes. Now you may think that the intelectual property thing is black and white, but not all people do. Not to mention just because something is law doesn't make it right, do we need an education on laws that are repealed because they are found to be wrong/excessive? What I find irrational about you is you refuse to see or listen to anything that doesn't agree with your narrow view!
Wow DarkKnight your ignorance and close mindedness are mind numbing!
First I want to say I never said I pirated anything, what I did say is that I think copyright/intellectual property laws have issues and need to be fixed.
Second I am sure as hell glad our founding fathers and great individuals like Rosa Parks didn't just lay down and be a doormat in the face of terrible laws, because they refused our country and everyone’s lives are better for it.
Now I am not equating pirating to those two things just letting you know that breaking the law is sometimes the only way to get it fixed period!
As for putting people in jail for pirating, that is the last thing we want to do. I suppose you want every pothead placed in jail also? Here in America we already incarcerate more people than any other nation and that is for other idiotic things like piracy. How about we look at why there is piracy and work on fixing those issues? If that takes the IP owners shouldering some responsibility and not litigating their own customers so be it. I think a lot of IP owners could learn a lot from companies like Stardock.
While it must be interesting for you to live in that black and white world of yours the rest of us live in a world where things aren’t so simple. I hope one day you will learn to deal with that, for everyone’s sake.
There are many great features available to you once you register, including:
Sign in or Create Account